“Uncertainty in the Empire of Routine: The Administrative Revolution of the Eighteenth-Century Qing State appeared last August from Harvard University Press. Its author, Maura Dykstra, is now an assistant professor of history at Yale.
In an extensive review that appeared in the Journal of Chinese History on August 31, George Qiao, an assistant professor of history and Asian languages and civilizations at Amherst College in Massachusetts, wrote that Dykstra’s book “fails to meet basic academic standards” and is “filled with misinformation.” ”
Auch aus China kommt vernichtende Kritik:
Zhou reviewed the 13 files from the Baxian archives that Dykstra used. The conclusion is that: 1 is properly used; 3 are correctly read but inaccurately interpreted; 8 are incorrect in both reading and interpretation; and 1 is completely unrelated to the issue addressed.
— Zoe DING (@zoeding_) September 26, 2023
OpenEdition schlägt Ihnen vor, diesen Beitrag wie folgt zu zitieren:
Klaus Graf (26. September 2023). Ein denkwürdiger Verriss. Archivalia. Abgerufen am 10. August 2026 von https://doi.org/10.58079/cikg